[MS] If we can have std::atomic

Some time ago, we peeked inside the atomic shared_ptr to see how it worked. Can we apply these same principles to create an atomic com_ptr?

Recall that the atomic shared_ptr operates by using the bottom bit of the control block pointer as a lock flag, so that nobody can change the value while we're copying the pointer and incrementing the reference count. Can we do this with a com_ptr?

We could use the same trick of using the bottom bit of the raw COM pointer as a lock flag. This is acceptable because COM pointers must be pointer-aligned (since they point to a vtable), so we know that the bottom bit of a valid COM pointer is clear. However, we run into trouble when trying to increment the reference count: The call to IUnknown::AddRef happens while the lock is held, but the AddRef is a call out to external code, and we don't know what it's going to do. We know what it's supposed to do (namely, increment the reference count), but it may take a circuitous route to get there, including passing through aggregated controlling unknowns, tear-off stubs, tear-offs of aggregated objects, weak outer pointers, and other fanciful characters.

We know that holding a lock while calling out to external code is a source of deadlocks, so holding a lock while calling out to a mystery implementation of IUnknown::AddRef is probably not a good idea.

Sorry.


Post Updated on April 25, 2025 at 03:00PM
Thanks for reading
from devamazonaws.blogspot.com

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Scenarios capability now generally available for Amazon Q in QuickSight - devamazonaws.blogspot.com

Today, AWS announces the general availability of the scenarios capability of Amazon Q in QuickSight. Amazon Q guides you through data analysis by uncovering hidden trends, making recommendations for your business, and intelligently suggesting next steps for deeper exploration—all in response to natural language interactions. Now anyone can explore past trends, forecast future scenarios, and model solutions without needing specialized skill, analyst support, or manual manipulation of data in spreadsheets. With its intuitive interface and step-by-step guidance, the scenarios capability of Amazon Q in QuickSight helps users perform complex data analysis up to 10x faster than spreadsheets. Whether you're optimizing marketing budgets, streamlining supply chains, or analyzing investments, Amazon Q makes advanced data analysis accessible so you can make data-driven decisions across your organization. This capability is accessible from any Amazon QuickSight dashboard, so you can move seam...
Read more

[MS] Introducing Pull Request Annotation for CodeQL and Dependency Scanning in GitHub Advanced Security for Azure DevOps - devamazonaws.blogspot.com

Image
In the world of software development, security is paramount. As developers, we strive to write clean, efficient, and most importantly, secure code. GitHub Advanced Security for Azure DevOps has always been at the forefront of providing tools that make it easier to build and release high-quality software. Today, we’re excited to announce a new feature release that will take your code security to the next level: PR (Pull Request) Annotation for CodeQL and Dependency Scanning. PR Annotation - What Does it Mean for You? Pull Request Annotation brings security insights directly into your development workflow. Here’s how it works: When you raise a Pull Request, CodeQL runs automatically, scanning for any potential security issues. Dependency Scanning concurrently checks for vulnerabilities in packages or libraries you might be using. If any issues are found, they are reported directly on the PR interface as annotations. Developers can see exactly what the problem is and where it occu...
Read more

AWS Console Mobile Application adds support for Amazon Lightsail - devamazonaws.blogspot.com

AWS customers can now access Amazon Lightsail from within the AWS Console Mobile App to monitor and manage Lightsail instances, containers, databases, network, storage, snapshots, domains and DNS while on the go. Visit the Services tab in the AWS Console Mobile App and select Lightsail to get started. The AWS Console Mobile App enables AWS customers monitor and manage a select set of resources and receive push notifications to stay informed and connected with their AWS resources while on-the-go. The sign-in process supports biometrics authentication, making access to AWS resources simple, secure, and quick. Lightsail offers easy-to-use virtual private server (VPS) instances, storage, databases, and more for a cost-effective monthly price. For AWS services not available natively, customers can access the AWS Management Console via an in-app browser to access service pages without additional authentication, manual navigation, or need to switch from the app to a browser. Visit the AWS...
Read more